0%
  • Home
  • Royal Family News
  • The Reviews Are In for Charles Spencer’s Swan Song. Critics Agree on One Thing: This Is Personal

The Reviews Are In for Charles Spencer’s Swan Song. Critics Agree on One Thing: This Is Personal

Share this story
Cover of Charles Spencer’s memoir Swan Song: Diana, My Sister
Charles Spencer’s memoir, Swan Song: Diana, My Sister. Image: Penguin Random House.

On publication day, reviewers are divided over whether Charles Spencer’s memoir succeeds as a tribute to Princess Diana or becomes something more combative. Across the criticism, however, the same tension keeps surfacing: love and grievance occupy the same pages.

By Mimi Gill, Royally Inspired

By the time Swan Song: Diana, My Sister officially reached bookstores on Tuesday, many of its most dramatic claims had already escaped into the wider royal conversation.

The first Swan Song reviews suggest that critics are wrestling with much the same contradiction.

There had been excerpts, interviews, a rare response from Buckingham Palace and renewed debate over events that took place nearly three decades ago. Charles Spencer had defended his recollections publicly, insisting that he was not attempting to damage the monarchy but to tell what he considers the truth about his sister’s life and the extraordinary week following her death.

Publication day, however, brought a different question.

Beyond the headlines, what do critics actually think of the book?

The answer is considerably more complicated than either Spencer’s supporters or his detractors might expect.

The early reviews do not agree on whether Swan Song ultimately works as a memoir. Some find moving material in Spencer’s recollections of the sister he knew before the rest of the world did. Others argue that his anger toward the Royal Family, and King Charles in particular, gradually overwhelms the tribute he says he intended to write.

Yet across some strikingly different reviews, a common impression emerges: this is not a detached biography of Princess Diana.

It is the story of Diana as remembered by a brother who is still grieving her, still angry about what happened to her and still determined to challenge the version of history he believes others have allowed to settle around her.

Book at a Glance

Swan Song: Diana, My Sister

Charles Spencer’s memoir of his sister, Princess Diana

Published September 22, 2026
Length 384 pages
U.S. Publisher Penguin Press
Formats Hardcover, ebook & audiobook

Love and Anger Are Sharing the Same Pages

Perhaps the neatest description comes from The New York Times, whose review characterizes Swan Song as a memoir filled with both “love and vengeance.”

That tension appears again and again in the critical response.

Spencer’s affection for Diana is rarely the part reviewers question. The more difficult issue is what happens when that affection collides with grievances that have clearly survived the passage of nearly thirty years.

The Guardian finds an emotionally complicated book, one capable of offering tender memories of Diana and the Spencer family while repeatedly returning to Spencer’s resentments. Its review points to the warmth of the childhood material, but argues that the memoir can become consumed by the author’s anger toward the Royal Family, journalists and others who have crossed his path.

That distinction matters because Swan Song arrives with an unusual burden.

Spencer is not merely remembering a famous sister. He is writing about a woman whose life has been analyzed, dramatized, mythologized and fought over for decades. Every new recollection enters an already crowded historical record.

His book is therefore being judged not only on what it reveals about Diana, but also on what it reveals about Charles Spencer.

The Critical Conversation

What the Reviews Are Really Debating

The Tribute Are Spencer’s intimate childhood memories the book’s greatest strength?
The Reckoning Does his anger toward the Royal Family eventually overshadow Diana herself?
The Witness How should readers weigh the memories of a brother who was both participant and observer?

Reviewers reach very different conclusions, but these questions keep surfacing.

The Childhood Diana May Be the Book’s Strongest Asset

Althorp House, the Spencer family estate in Northamptonshire
Althorp House in Northamptonshire, the Spencer family estate. Photo: Andrew Walker / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.5.

Where the reviews appear most receptive is in the material that belongs uniquely to Spencer.

Before Diana became the Princess of Wales, she was his older sister.

They were the youngest Spencer children, sharing a complicated childhood shaped by privilege, their parents’ painful separation, boarding schools and the peculiar emotional codes of the British aristocracy.

That is territory Spencer can claim in a way almost no other living writer can.

Cover of Swan Song: Diana, My Sister by Charles Spencer

Book cover courtesy of Penguin Books.

Interested in reading it yourself?

Swan Song: Diana, My Sister by Charles Spencer is now available.

Buy on Amazon

Affiliate disclosure: If you purchase through this link, Royally Inspired may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

The Times notes the book’s exploration of the damage left by the Spencer family’s fractured childhood and sees something larger in Spencer’s effort to confront the emotional silence of the world in which he and Diana were raised. The review describes the memoir not simply as another royal tell-all, but partly as an attempt to examine an upper-class culture in which difficult experiences were often endured rather than discussed.

Those passages may ultimately prove more valuable than the accusations currently commanding the headlines.

Readers already know Princess Diana as the global humanitarian, royal rebel, fashion icon and endlessly photographed celebrity.

Far fewer knew “Duch,” the girl Charles Spencer says he roamed the family estate with, confided in and laughed with long before photographers followed her every move.

The publisher has emphasized precisely that intimacy, presenting Swan Song as the story of Diana from someone who knew her before she belonged, in some sense, to everyone else.

Then the Memoir Becomes a Reckoning

The difficulty for some reviewers is that the quieter family portrait does not remain quiet for long.

King Charles occupies a substantial and controversial place in Spencer’s telling. So do Prince Philip, Queen Elizabeth II, the machinery of the Palace and the decisions made after Diana’s death.

Flowers and tributes left at Kensington Palace after Princess Diana’s death
Flowers and tributes left at Kensington Palace after Princess Diana’s death. Photo: Maxwell Hamilton / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0.

The claims have been widely reported. Spencer alleges, among other things, deeply insensitive remarks and behavior from the then-Prince Charles and recounts a bitter dispute over whether William and Harry should walk behind their mother’s coffin. Buckingham Palace took the unusual step of responding publicly to one of Spencer’s recollections, suggesting that profound grief can affect memory and judgment. Spencer has stood by his account.

Royal History 101

Why the Funeral Procession Still Matters

The walk behind Diana’s coffin became one of the defining images of the days after her death.

1
Diana died in Paris. Princess Diana died on August 31, 1997, at age 36.
2
Britain gathered for her funeral. Her funeral was held at Westminster Abbey on September 6 as enormous crowds gathered in London and a global television audience watched.
3
William and Harry walked behind her coffin. William, 15, and Harry, 12, joined their father, Prince Charles, their grandfather Prince Philip and their uncle Earl Spencer in the procession to Westminster Abbey.
Today’s context: In Swan Song, Spencer returns to the question of how the young princes came to take part in that procession, making a moment millions remember visually part of the book’s present-day dispute.

This is where the reviews begin to separate sharply.

The chief literary critic for The Times interprets the memoir almost as a “Shakespearean blood feud,” with Spencer defending not only Diana but his own family against the House of Windsor. The review finds legitimate emotional and historical material in the book while questioning whether some of its most dramatic allegations push the narrative toward theatrical score-settling.

The Telegraph is much less forgiving. Its review argues that a book ostensibly about Diana becomes increasingly preoccupied with Spencer himself, criticizing what it sees as self-importance running alongside the genuine affection for his sister.

Those are very different degrees of criticism, but they are reacting to the same feature of the memoir.

Charles Spencer has not written himself out of Diana’s story.

Quite the opposite.

Can a Brother Ever Be an Objective Witness?

Perhaps that is the question at the center of Swan Song, whether Spencer intended it or not.

A sibling may possess memories no historian could ever recover. He may remember a joke, a childhood nickname, a look across a room or the way his sister behaved when nobody important was watching.

But intimacy creates its own complications.

The person closest to a story is not necessarily the person standing far enough away to see every part of it clearly.

That does not make Spencer’s memories meaningless. Nor does disagreement prove them false. Memory, particularly memory shaped by grief and family conflict, is rarely a perfectly preserved transcript of events.

What it does mean is that Swan Song is probably most useful when read for what it openly is: one brother’s account.

Not the final word on Princess Diana.

Not the Palace’s version.

Not William’s or Harry’s.

Charles Spencer’s.

A Reader’s Guide

Three Lenses for Reading Swan Song

Personal Memory Spencer can preserve moments and details no outside biographer could have witnessed.
Public Record Some events can also be considered alongside contemporary reporting, documents and recorded history.
Competing Accounts When memories conflict, disagreement itself becomes part of the historical record.

What the Swan Song Reviews Agree On

The temptation with a royal book this heavily publicized is to divide reaction into two camps: explosive truth-telling on one side and vindictive score-settling on the other.

The better criticism is more complicated than that.

A memoir can be loving and angry. A writer can possess valuable memories and personal blind spots. A brother can sincerely believe he is protecting his sister’s legacy while also carrying grievances of his own.

Those ideas do not cancel one another out.

In fact, their coexistence may explain why Swan Song is generating such a strong response.

Nearly thirty years after Diana’s death, Charles Spencer is clearly not finished wrestling with what happened to his sister, or with the people and institutions he believes failed her.

Readers may disagree over whether that makes him the ideal person to tell this story.

It unquestionably makes him a deeply invested one.

Diana Remains at the Center

For all the attention surrounding King Charles, palace rebuttals and disputed conversations, there is a quieter question readers may want to keep in mind as they open the book.

Do they leave Swan Song feeling that they know Diana better?

That may ultimately matter more than any single headline generated during publication week.

Princess Diana in the Yellow Oval Room of the White House in 1985
Princess Diana in the Yellow Oval Room of the White House in 1985. Public domain via Wikimedia Commons.

Spencer has said that he wanted younger generations, including people who never experienced Diana’s extraordinary public presence, to understand the person behind the mythology. His recollections of their childhood and family life offer something the endless archive of royal coverage cannot quite reproduce: the memory of Diana before she became an institution in her own right.

Taken together, the Swan Song reviews suggest that Spencer has written something more complicated than either a simple tribute or a royal reckoning.

The critics may continue arguing over whether Spencer has written a tribute, a reckoning or something uncomfortably suspended between the two.

Perhaps Swan Song is all three.

And for a book written out of a relationship as complicated as love, grief and family usually are, that may be the most revealing review of all.

Interested in reading Swan Song for yourself? Find it on Amazon

Sources:

The Times: Review of Swan Song: Diana, My Sister
The Telegraph: Review of Charles Spencer’s Swan Song
The New York Times, The Guardian, Penguin, Associated Press

What’s Your Take?

We’ve shared the story. Now we’d love to hear from you! What do you think? Share your thoughts below.
No login required to comment.

guest

0 Comments

You Might Also Like

Official booking photograph of Thomas Markle Sr. in an orange jail uniform, released November 10, 2026
Thomas Markle Sr. Faces Competency Hearing in Tampa Federal Court
Nov 19, 2026

Thomas Markle Sr., Meghan’s estranged father, is due in federal court in Tampa for a…

The columned Royal Opera House facade in Covent Garden, seen from the street.
The Royal Ballet School and The Royal Ballet: Who Does What?
Nov 19, 2026

The school trains dancers; the companies perform. A clear guide to the royal ballet names,…

Queen Victoria in a dark dress and white veil in an 1887 portrait by Alexander Bassano.
Who Edited Queen Victoria’s Journals, and What Survives?
Nov 19, 2026

What Princess Beatrice copied, what remains in Queen Victoria’s own handwriting, and how readers can…

Buildings at King Edward Point sit beside the water below the mountains of South Georgia.
Why Princess Anne Visited a Fisheries Lab on South Georgia
Nov 18, 2026

Princess Anne stopped at King Edward Point, where scientists study the fish and wildlife of…